PCA vs. HHA: What You Need to Know Before Hiring

When you have a loved one’s who’s dealing with health issues you want a caregiver who’s trained to provide some degree of health support. That’s a home health aide (HHA).

But if you’re looking for some to provide personal care or companion care while you’re away, you’re looking for a PCA (Personal Care Aide).

The PCA vs. HHA comparison is common when looking for home care services.

PCAs excel in non-medical care, offering companionship and daily assistance, while HHAs provide both medical and non-medical services, making them suited for complex healthcare needs.

In this guide, we’ll provide the most extensive answer to the common question: What is the difference between PCA and HHA, and when do you hire which?

PCA Vs. HHA: What's the difference between Personal Care Aides and Home Health Care Aides.

Home Health Aide vs Personal Care Aide: The Key Differences

Key Differences	Personal Care Aides (PCA)	Home Health Aides (HHA)
Scope of Services	Non-medical care, companionship, assistance with ADLs	Medical and non-medical care, wound care, medication administration
Training and Education	Focus on emotional support and non-medical caregiving	Comprehensive training, medical and non-medical skills
Specialization	Ideal for personalized care at home or group settings	Commonly found in hospitals and nursing homes, specialized care

Need help finding an PCA or HHA for your Loved One?

Professional Caregiver helping senior in Boston

We’re happy to help you find a vetted and compassionate caregiver to care for your loved one. Get in touch with us and tell us what you’re looking for specifically.
Find My Caregiver Today

Personal Care Aides (PCA): A Closer Look

Let’s understand the role of a Personal Care Aide, often regarded as a professional companion caregiver for seniors or persons with disabilities.

What Does a PCA Do?

A Personal Care Aide (PCA) is someone who provides personal care services, assists with daily tasks and provides companionship. They work in private homes, assisted living facilities, and even group homes. Their main goal is to ensure a comfortable and independent life for their clients.

A PCA’s responsibilities include:

Helping with bathing (shower assistance), grooming, and dressing
Preparing meals and assisting with feeding
Providing emotional support and companionship
Performing light housekeeping and laundry
Running errands and arranging transportation

Qualities of Professional Caregivers to hire from home care agencies in Boston

These interactions foster a sense of companionship and emotional connection, which can significantly improve the quality of life for your loved ones in their care.

During my time as a PCA, I cared for a really interesting single Mexican woman right here in Boston. She was a warm-hearted woman in her 90s, and we discovered a shared love for gardening.

I had developed an interest in gardening during my time in West Africa, while she was raised by Mexican farmers.

We spent afternoons tending to her small garden, and the joy on her face when flowers bloomed will forever be etched in my memory.

The emotional bond we developed over time made our caregiving journey together all the more special.

Education and Training Requirements for PCAs

Becoming a PCA does not typically require completing a training program or obtaining certification. Formal education beyond a high school diploma is not always mandatory.

PCAs often complete their training onsite under the supervision of registered nurses.

Pros and Cons of Hiring a PCA

Why hire a professional caregiver for you or your loved ones? Global One Home Care

Hiring a personal professional caregiver
comes with numerous benefits. Their personalized care and compassionate approach allow your loved one to remain in the comfort of their own home, which can significantly enhance their overall well-being.

Additionally, PCAs are often more affordable than other professional caregivers, making them an accessible option for many families.

However, it’s essential to consider certain limitations of PCA services. As non-medical caregivers, PCAs may not have the expertise to handle complex medical situations.

If your loved one requires specialized medical attention, it may be more appropriate to consider the services of a Home Health Aide (HHA).

Home Health Aides (HHAs): What Makes Them Different?

A Home Health Aide (HHA) does everything a PCA does, but with additional medical responsibilities. If your loved one needs basic medical care at home, an HHA is the better choice.

What are the benefits of home health care for seniors or disabled adults and their families?

Home Health Aides, or HHAs, possess an additional layer of medical training, making them qualified to provide basic medical care to their clients.

They work under the supervision of registered nurses or healthcare professionals and often provide support to individuals requiring more intensive medical attention.

An HHA’s medical duties can include:

Monitoring vital signs (blood pressure, pulse, etc.)
Assisting with medication reminders
Providing wound care and changing bandages
Helping patients manage chronic illnesses
Assisting in post-surgery recovery

Because of this added medical training, HHAs often work under the supervision of nurses or healthcare professionals.

The distinctive feature of HHAs is their ability to perform medical tasks, such as wound care, monitoring vital signs, and administering medications.

This medical expertise enables them to provide specialized care for dementia patients, or support individuals with chronic illnesses, post-surgery recovery, or those transitioning from hospital to home care.

Education and Training Requirements for HHAs

Education creates a major difference between HHA and PCA.

Becoming an HHA necessitates completing a state-approved training program that encompasses both non-medical and medical aspects of caregiving.

HHAs working for home care agencies certified by Medicare or Medicaid must meet specific federal requirements, ensuring their competency in medical care.

Pros and Cons of Hiring an HHA

One of the significant advantages of hiring an HHA is the assurance of skilled medical care for your loved one. For individuals with complex medical needs, HHAs become an invaluable lifeline.

However, it’s essential to consider the potentially higher costs associated with hiring an HHA, especially when compared to the more affordable PCA services.

Home Health Aide vs. PCA: Which One Should You Choose?

Discover the key differences between Personal Care Aides (PCAs) and Home Health Aides (HHAs), commonly referred to as PCA vs. HHA. A comprehensive guide

Think About Your Loved One’s Needs

If you’re unsure whether to hire a PCA or HHA, ask yourself:

Does my loved one need help with daily tasks but not medical care? → Hire a PCA
Do they need medical assistance at home (e.g., wound care, medication reminders)? → Hire an HHA

This is the key in the PCA and HHA difference that families must consider.

We’ve summed up the differences between HHA vs PCA under the following 3 categories:

Scope of service
Training and Education
Specialization and care settings.

Want to learn more about home care and home health care? Here is an article that provides more clarity on the differences between home care and Home Health care.

Similar: What Is the Difference Between a Caregiver and PCA?

This is another common question you’ll deal with when choosing the right care service for your loved one.

A PCA is a type of caregiver, but not all caregivers are PCAs. Caregivers may have different levels of training, while a PCA has specialized experience in personal care services.

Home Care vs. Home Health Care: What’s the Difference? – Ultimate Guide

Final Thoughts

If you’re still wondering “what is the difference between PCA and HHA?” or “what’s the difference between PCA and HHA?”, just remember:

PCAs are best for non-medical personal care.
HHAs provide personal care PLUS basic medical assistance.

Both are essential in home care, but your choice should be based on your loved one’s needs.

Author Profile

Dr. Ella Njike

Founder and CEO at Global One Home Care | Website

Dr. Ella Njike is the branch administrator for Global One Home Care, Boston, an agency that provides quality care for seniors and kids or adults with disabilities. With a Doctorate and extensive experience working in the healthcare industry, Dr Ella brings a unique understanding to the challenges families face. Through Global One Home Care Boston, he ensures that care extends beyond daily tasks, focuses on building genuine connections and respecting each family's journey.

PCA vs. HHA: Differences between Personal Care and Home Health Care Aides