-
Talk to Our Care Planner
The Greatest Risks of Hiring a Private Caregiver
It was 6 AM on a Tuesday, and my client, Mrs. Henderson, a sweet lady with advanced dementia, needed her morning medications. Her usual private caregiver wasn’t answering. Mrs. Henderson’s daughter, frantic, called me, her emergency backup.
I raced over, heart pounding. It turned out the caregiver had a family emergency out of state, with no notice. Mrs. Henderson was safe, but her daughter was in tears, exhausted from a sleepless night worrying, and now facing a full day trying to find someone, anyone, to fill in.
If you’re looking into hiring a private caregiver, you need to understand that what seems like a straightforward path can quickly become a minefield.
The most dangerous risks of hiring a private caregiver go from serious safety concerns, theft of valuables and legal liabilities to financial pitfalls and overwhelming stress. But by the end of this post, you’ll know exactly what risks to look out for and how to find true peace of mind.
Here’s a breakdown of the critical risks of hiring a private caregiver that every family should be aware of, based on both my experience and extensive research:
5 of the Greatest Risks of Hiring a Private Caregiver
The risks of hiring a private caregiver are often hidden in plain sight, because what starts as a search for help can, in a blink, turn you into an unexpected, unprepared, and utterly overwhelmed household employer.
And trust me, the IRS doesn’t send warm, fuzzy care notes. They send bills.
The desire to maintain a loved one’s independence within their familiar home environment, driven by the overall pros and cons of aging in place, makes private hiring an attractive option for many. If you’re considering this path, you need to know what you’re really signing up for.
1. Inadequate Vetting and Background Checks: The Unknown Stranger in Your Home
Brutal honesty: when you hire a private caregiver, you become the detective, the HR department, and, sometimes, the emotional punching bag. And the first, most crucial step – the background check – is where most families fall flat.
I once worked with a family who swore by their “background check” – a quick online search and a few phone calls to references listed on the resume. This “online check” is incomplete, often inaccurate, and offers a false sense of security.
What they missed was the gold standard of a fingerprint-based FBI check, the kind only agencies can reliably access. It’s like looking at a puddle and claiming you’ve seen the whole ocean.
Think about it: are you checking abuse and neglect registries? Sanction checks? Sex offender registries? Drug testing? Verifying their driving history if they’ll be driving your loved one?
Are you calling every reference and asking specific, probing questions, not just “Were they good?” (Because who lists a bad reference, right?) I’ve seen people avoid direct questions, give vague answers, or flat-out refuse a background check. Alarm bells, folks!
I remember one woman who seemed so sweet, but something felt off. When I casually asked about her previous client, she got shifty. Later, a colleague at the assisted living facility told me she’d been dismissed from there for “unexplained disappearances” of small valuables.
She never showed up on any public record check. You need to know that these checks are not just about criminal history; they’re about revealing character and reliability. And doing it properly yourself? Practically impossible.
You might also find it helpful to understand the different types of caregivers and their typical qualifications to set realistic expectations.
2. Legal and Financial Liabilities: You’re a Household Employer Now (Surprise!)
This is where things get truly gnarly. The IRS, bless their cotton socks, doesn’t care about your good intentions. When you hire a private caregiver directly, you’re almost certainly a “household employer.”
That friendly caregiver you pay in cash under the table? Yeah, that’s tax evasion. And it’s not a cute, quirky little secret.
As a household employer in the US, you’re now responsible for payroll taxes (Social Security, Medicare – both your share and theirs), federal and state unemployment taxes, and potentially even withholding income tax.
You need an Employer Identification Number (EIN). You need to keep meticulous records of every single hour worked, including breaks, even if they’re just “suffering or permitted to work” while watching TV. If you don’t, and a dispute arises, their word against yours could be enough.
As for paying by the hour, many states (hello, California!) mandate hourly pay, not a daily rate or salary. And overtime? Oh yes, caregivers are entitled to overtime!
Trust me, the minute a caregiver files for unemployment or a wage dispute, that “under-the-table domino effect” starts, and it’s a messy, costly pile-up. Understanding the true 24/7 in-home care cost goes far beyond the hourly wage when you’re the employer.
Working with a home care agency is just a no brainer. It’s unbelievable. They take away all the “employer’s” burden, so you only have to worry about NOTHING.
3. Safety, Security, and Privacy Risks: Protecting Your Loved One and Their Assets
I saw private homes that were, frankly, health hazards. Trip hazards, bad lighting, unsanitary conditions. As a professional, I could flag these things, but a private caregiver might feel awkward or even fear losing their job if they point out your overflowing cat litter boxes or that cracked step.
But the hard stuff is theft and financial exploitation. It’s a sad reality, but it’s “becoming more common.” Your loved one, perhaps vulnerable due to age or cognitive decline, is essentially giving a stranger access to their world.
Valuables, cash, financial documents, prescription medications – all of it. I’ve heard whispers, seen signs: small items disappearing, unusual bank withdrawals. It’s the “trust paradox” – the very intimacy that makes private care appealing also creates heightened vulnerability.
A camera can be a deterrent, sure, but know your state laws on recording. And listen to your gut. If something feels off, it usually is.
I worked with a wonderful client whose rings went missing. The family was convinced the new private caregiver was responsible. It tore them apart. Turns out, the client, in her confusion, had hidden them. But the suspicion, the accusation, the breakdown of trust – it’s a terrifying thing to live through, even if unfounded.
As for privacy, HIPAA isn’t just for hospitals. Your caregiver is handling deeply personal and health information. Passwords, medical records – are they secured? Is their mobile device encrypted if they’re using it for your loved one’s care?
For families that are really seeking help with personal care services; we can all agree these needs are best met by vetted professionals working through a licensed home care agency.
4. Care Quality and Compatibility Challenges: When Expectations Clash with Reality
I’ve seen families assume a caregiver can do everything – be a nurse, a chef, a maid for the whole house, a chauffeur, and a therapist. No.
Caregivers have a scope of practice. We can remind about meds, but we can’t change dosages. We can’t give injections unless specially licensed. This “professionalization gap” is real.
You might think you’re getting comprehensive medical care from your private hire, but you might just be getting someone with good intentions and very limited training.
If your family is primarily focused on daily assistance with bathing, dressing, and mobility, it’s crucial to understand the distinct offerings when comparing personal care services with assisted living facilities.
It’s also worth knowing the differences between a Personal Care Aide (PCA) and a Home Health aid (HHA) or perhaps an ordinary caregiver versus a CNA (Certified nursing assistant) to understand their respective training and limitations.
Finally, to really clarify the level of medical assistance you can expect from your private caregiver, it’s essential to understand the distinction between home care and home health care.
And then there’s reliability. Maria, the caregiver who disappeared? That’s the private hire risk. When I worked for an agency (before starting my own), if I got sick, they had a vetted backup already on standby.
For private hires, you are “on the hook for finding backup care.” Can you drop everything to provide care for days, or weeks? Can you find someone trustworthy at 6 AM on a Tuesday? These are important questions.
If you went the agency route, professional care agencies can arrange 24-hour care for the elderly with built-in backup. This is again, arguably the best solution to the risks of uncertainty and unreliability.
I’ve seen family members spiral into burnout trying to manage it all, their own health deteriorating as they try to keep all these plates spinning.
5. Emotional Toll for Families: The Unseen Burden of Oversight
Caring for aging parents, even with the assistance of a private caregiver, places immense strain on even the most resilient individuals.
Family caregivers consistently report higher levels of stress than non-caregivers.
Managing a private caregiver adds substantial oversight responsibilities for the family (e.g., acting as HR, managing payroll, scheduling, resolving conflicts, finding backup care), directly contributing to this already significant emotional and physical stress.
This “invisible management burden” means that the family member coordinating care experiences heightened levels of stress, anxiety, and a greater risk of burnout.
This burnout can then directly impair their ability to provide effective oversight, communicate clearly, or identify potential red flags regarding the private caregiver, ultimately leading to compromised care quality or missed opportunities to intervene in problematic situations.
This unseen burden can lead to intense stress and feelings of being trapped caring for an elderly parent.
If your loved one has dementia or Alzheimer’s, for example, the complexities and risks are even greater, necessitating specialized care and consistent oversight.
Home Care Agencies the Solution to the Risks of Hiring Private Caregivers?
I’ve seen the raw, unfiltered reality of caregiving from every angle. And while the allure of directly hiring a private caregiver is strong, the risks of hiring a private caregiver are real, often hidden, and can have devastating consequences for your loved one and your family.
This is exactly why home care agencies exist. They bring peace of mind, not hidden liabilities or sleepless nights. They take all these risks, and we mitigate them for you.
I’ll just throw in a selfish pitch. Here’s how we at Global One Home Care work tirelessly to keep you away from any of risks of hiring a private caregiver yourself.
- Rigorous Vetting? You Bet.
We do the exhaustive, multi-layered background checks—criminal, abuse registries, driving records, drug screenings—the ones you can’t easily do on your own. We verify references and ensure every caregiver is not just kind and compassionate, but truly qualified and trustworthy.
This is why hiring professional caregivers in Boston through an agency like ours makes all the difference.
- No Employer Hassle.
Forget IRS forms, payroll taxes, and worker’s compensation. When you hire through Global One Home Care, you are NOT the employer. We handle all the legal and financial heavy lifting, eliminating your liabilities and ensuring compliance.
- Professional Training & Support.
Our caregivers are not just experienced; they are trained in elder care best practices, dementia care, first aid, and medication reminders.
They have a professional team behind them, ensuring they have the support and resources they need to provide the highest quality of care. This is a key reason why to hire a professional caregiver.
- Reliability & Backup.
If your assigned caregiver is sick or on vacation, we seamlessly provide a qualified, vetted replacement. Care never stops.
- Careful Matching & Oversight.
We take the time to understand your loved one’s personality and needs, carefully matching them with a caregiver who is not only skilled but also a good personal fit. We provide ongoing supervision and dedicated support, ensuring consistent, quality care.
Ultimately, choosing the right path means weighing all your options, whether it’s understanding the nuances of private versus agency care, or even considering the broader choice between assisted living and in-home care for your loved one.
And if you insist on taking on this journey yourself, at least use our free guide: What to Ask When Hiring In-Home Care.
Ready for True Peace of Mind?
Talk to a care expert today to discuss your care needs and learn more about how we can provide peace of mind.
You want 100% trust? We built our foundation on it. Don’t navigate the complex, risky world of private caregiver hiring alone. Let us handle the hidden challenges, so you can focus on what truly matters: your loved one’s well-being and your own peace of mind.
Dr. Ella Njike is the CEO and founder of Global One Home Care Boston, a Boston-based agency providing compassionate in-home support for seniors and individuals with disabilities. With a Doctorate and extensive experience working in the healthcare industry, Dr Ella brings a unique understanding to the challenges families face. He established Global One Home Care to ensure that care extends beyond daily tasks, focusing on building genuine connections and respecting each individual's journey. Dr. Njike is deeply committed to creating an environment where clients feel truly valued and at home.
Contact us
We aim to be an active partner in your care, not to take over. You are the CEO of your care, and we support you in managing it effectively.
Here are some features of our Global One Home Care
- 24/7 access to care
- Customized care plans
- Supervisory visits
- Caregiver introductions
- Nutritional planning
- Respite support
- Companionship
- Mobility assistance
- Durable Medical Equipment recommendations
- Errands and Shopping
- Fall Prevention
- ADLs